Washington Court of Appeals clarifies and tightens the standard for expert admissibility in unpublished case.
ABSTRACT: In a recent case, Cundy v. BNSF, Washington’s Court of Appeals clarified admissibility of expert opinions in Washington. An expert opinion must pass both Frye and ER 702. Frye analyzes the validity of the underlying science, while ER 702 analyzes the reliability of the expert. This two-step analysis moves Washington closer to the more rigorous federal Rule 702.
Washington is part of a minority of jurisdictions that still adheres to the Frye test for expert witnesses. Under the Frye test, an expert’s opinion is admissible if it enjoys “general acceptance in the relevant scientific community.” The purpose of this test is to determine whether novel scientific evidence has a valid scientific basis.
To be admissible in Washington courts however, an expert’s opinion must also comply with Washington Evidence Rule (ER) 702. ER 702 is similar but not identical to the federal rule 702 governing expert admissibility.[1] Washington’s ER 702, which applies to “scientific, technical, or other specialized knowledge” (i.e., expert testimony), makes such testimony admissible if it “assist[s] the trier of fact to understand the evidence or to determine a fact in issue.” Stated simply, under ER 702, expert testimony is admissible if “helpful” to the jury (or the court in a bench trial) to understand the evidence or decide a relevant fact question. To be “helpful,” an opinion must be reliable in that it rests on scientific or other technical evidence, not speculation or belief.
The Cundy case, which is unpublished, shows what this two-step analysis looks like in practice. The Court in that case evaluated the admissibility of a plaintiff’s expert who had authored an opinion which stated that the plaintiff’s colon cancer was caused by years of working around diesel engine exhaust. The expert’s opinion was based on a review of scientific literature, epidemiological studies, and data related to the carcinogenic effects of diesel exhaust as well as the Bradford Hill criteria (a method of determining medical causation), and differential diagnosis.
First, the Court held that the expert’s opinion was not subject to a Frye challenge because its methodology was not “novel.” Literature review, the Bradford Hill criteria, and differential diagnoses are all well-established methods in the medical community. That is enough to pass the Frye test.
However, Division III nevertheless upheld the trial court’s exclusion of the opinion because the expert systematically misrepresented what the science said about diesel exhaust causing colorectal cancer. It was evident based on the record that the expert misstated the conclusions of various studies, cherry-picked data, applied peer-supported studies about lung and bladder cancer to plaintiff’s colorectal cancer, dismissed evidence of plaintiff’s smoking, and failed to apply the methodologies he said he did. The Court explained that these were challenges to the expert’s reliability, not the underlying scientific methods he said he employed, and therefore implicated ER 702 but not Frye.
The importance of this opinion, while unpublished, should not be understated. The reliability analysis above moves Washington’s standard for admission of expert testimony, which has long been flexible, closer to the more rigorous standard in Fed. R. Evid. 702 which explicitly incorporates an analysis of whether the expert’s testimony is “the product of reliable principles and methods” (Fed. R. Evid. 702(c)) and “reflects a reliable application of the principles and methods to the facts of the case” (Fed. R. Evid. 702(d)). To the extent the Cudy court’s analysis is adopted by other divisions of Washington’s court of appeals or, ultimately, the state Supreme Court, this will move Washington’s standard for expert testimony further away from “junk science” and toward a more rigorous scientific or technical analysis already incorporated in Federal law.[1] Under the most recent amendments to Fed. R. Evid. 702, that rule and not common law decisions like Daubert v. Merrill Dow Pharms. generally governs admissibility of experts in federal court.
About Product Liability Law Blog
Baker Sterchi's Product Liability Blog examines significant developments, trends and topics in product liability law of interest to individuals and product manufacturers, distributors and sellers. Learn more about the editor, Greg Odom, and our Product Liability practice.
Subscribe via email
Subscribe to rss feeds
RSS FeedsABOUT baker sterchi blogs
Baker Sterchi Cowden & Rice LLC (Baker Sterchi) publishes this website as a service to our clients, colleagues and others, for informational purposes only. These materials are not intended to create an attorney-client relationship, and are not a substitute for sound legal advice. You should not base any action or lack of action on any information included in our website, without first seeking appropriate legal or other professional advice. If you contact us through our website or via email, no attorney-client relationship is created, and no confidential information should be transmitted. Communication with Baker Sterchi by e-mail or other transmissions over the Internet may not be secure, and you should not send confidential electronic messages that are not adequately encrypted.
The hiring of an attorney is an important decision, which should not be based solely on information appearing on our website. To the extent our website has provided links to other Internet resources, those links are not under our control, and we are not responsible for their content. We do our best to provide you current, accurate information; however, we cannot guarantee that this information is the most current, correct or complete. In addition, you should not take this information as a promise or indication of future results.
Disclaimer
The Product Liability Law Blog is made available by Baker Sterchi Cowden & Rice LLC for educational purposes only as well as to give you general information and a general understanding of the law, not to provide specific legal advice. Your use of this blog site alone creates no attorney client relationship between you and the firm.
Confidential information
Do not include confidential information in comments or other feedback or messages related to the Product Liability Law Blog, as these are neither confidential nor secure methods of communicating with attorneys. The Product Liability Law Blog should not be used as a substitute for competent legal advice from a licensed professional attorney in your state.













