Ready, Set, PREP! Applying PREP Act Immunity under Schmidt to Employment Claims—and Beyond.
ABSTRACT: Could the specific language of an FDA authorization for a COVID-19 test be the red light or green light for a hostile-work-environment claim? The answer, surprisingly, is yes. Employers should consider PREP Act immunity when assessing claims related in any way to COVID-19 or other major outbreaks.
In Schmidt v. City of Pasadena, the Ninth Circuit held that PREP Act immunity barred an employee’s claims against the City, including a hostile-work-environment claim. But what is the PREP Act, and how can it apply to employment-related claims?
The Public Readiness and Emergency Preparedness (“PREP”) Act is a 2005 federal statute providing immunity from “claims for loss” arising from actions taken to prevent the spread of disease. It is effective only during periods when the Secretary of Health and Human Services has made an emergency declaration placing the Act into effect. This occurred during the COVID-19 pandemic, when the Health Secretary made a number of declarations that have been in place from 2020 through the present. When the PREP Act is in effect, immunity applies to “covered persons” engaged in “covered countermeasures.” A covered person can be a governmental entity or a private person or business entity. Covered countermeasures are those that are enumerated within the Health Secretary’s declaration putting the Act into effect and authorized by the FDA. For example, and speaking broadly here, a clinic administering FDA-approved COVID-19 vaccines during the declaration-period of the COVID-19 pandemic would likely be immune from claims for loss under the PREP Act.
The Ninth Circuit’s decision in Schmidt focused on the breadth of the immunity provided by the PREP Act. An employee of the City of Pasadena used a religious exemption to opt out of vaccination during the COVID-19 pandemic. Because the employee had opted out of vaccination, the City instead required him to wear a mask at work and test for COVID-19.
After going through this regimen, the employee sued the City on several theories of liability including a hostile workplace because, he alleged, his masking and testing made known to other employees of the City that he had taken a religious exemption. The City moved to dismiss the employee’s complaint, and, after amendments to the complaint, obtained dismissal, in part because the employee had failed to allege a waiver of immunity under the PREP Act.
On appeal, the employee argued that the City had not engaged in a “covered countermeasure.” In ruling that the City’s masking and testing policies were “covered countermeasures,” the Ninth Circuit noted that the declarations of the Health Secretary are to be construed broadly. The employee argued that testing and masking were not authorized countermeasures because they were not proven to be effective. The Court analyzed the language of the FDA’s authorization for the specific type of test administered by the City. Even though the test had been proven effective for nasal swabs but not saliva samples, the authorization for the test was not written to exclude methods of testing beyond nasal swabbing. As for masking, the Court noted that masks were included as countermeasures to “prevent the spread” of COVID-19.
Notably, while the district court had dismissed only some of the employee’s claims due to PREP Act immunity, the Ninth Circuit went further and dismissed all of the employee’s claims based on such immunity. In doing so, the Ninth Circuit clarified that the PREP Act’s scope is not limited by cause of action and instead applies to any cause of action for which there is a “claim for loss” caused by a covered person administering a covered countermeasure. This holding is in line with the Tenth Circuit’s holding in Dressen v. AstraZeneca AB, 182 F.4th 1232 (10th Cir.), decided in July of this year. The holding is significant because it makes clear that PREP Act immunity applies to employment claims and other claims that may not immediately come to mind when considering immunity from actions taken to stop the spread of disease. As such, employers would do well to be aware of the Health Secretary’s declarations under the PREP Act and tailor their policies to conform to the contours of the declaration, when applicable, to minimize liability.
No Notice, No Constructive Discharge: Lessons from Pronk ...
Washington's Personnel-File Law: What Employers Should Consider in Light of SHB 1308 ...
About Employment & Labor Law Blog
Baker Sterchi's Employment & Labor Law Blog examines topics and developments of interest to employers, Human Resources professionals, and others with an interest in recent legal developments concerning the workplace. This blog is focused on the Midwest and Pacific Northwest and on major developments under federal law and at the EEOC and NLRB. Learn more about the editor, David Eisenberg, and our Employment & Labor practice.
Subscribe via email
Subscribe to rss feeds
RSS FeedsABOUT baker sterchi blogs
Baker Sterchi Cowden & Rice LLC (Baker Sterchi) publishes this website as a service to our clients, colleagues and others, for informational purposes only. These materials are not intended to create an attorney-client relationship, and are not a substitute for sound legal advice. You should not base any action or lack of action on any information included in our website, without first seeking appropriate legal or other professional advice. If you contact us through our website or via email, no attorney-client relationship is created, and no confidential information should be transmitted. Communication with Baker Sterchi by e-mail or other transmissions over the Internet may not be secure, and you should not send confidential electronic messages that are not adequately encrypted.
The hiring of an attorney is an important decision, which should not be based solely on information appearing on our website. To the extent our website has provided links to other Internet resources, those links are not under our control, and we are not responsible for their content. We do our best to provide you current, accurate information; however, we cannot guarantee that this information is the most current, correct or complete. In addition, you should not take this information as a promise or indication of future results.
Disclaimer
The Employment & Labor Law Blog is made available by Baker Sterchi Cowden & Rice LLC for educational purposes only as well as to give you general information and a general understanding of the law, not to provide specific legal advice. Your use of this blog site alone creates no attorney client relationship between you and the firm.
Confidential information
Do not include confidential information in comments or other feedback or messages related to the Employment & Labor Law Blog, as these are neither confidential nor secure methods of communicating with attorneys. The Employment & Labor Law Blog should not be used as a substitute for competent legal advice from a licensed professional attorney in your state.











