Summary Judgment Secured for Client on Missouri Merchandising Practices Act Claim in Construction Dispute
Baker Sterchi obtained partial summary judgment for a property restoration contractor on a Missouri Merchandising Practices Act (MMPA) claim arising from the reconstruction of a fire-damaged home.
The homeowner alleged that the contractor failed to correct construction defects, honor a workmanship warranty and comply with applicable building codes. He asserted claims under the MMPA and for breach of contract and/or express warranty.
The U.S. District Court for the Western District of Missouri found that, even when viewed in the homeowner’s favor, the evidence did not support a finding that the contractor engaged in an unfair practice, deception or false promise under the MMPA. The court concluded that the alleged deficiencies supported a contract dispute and that additional allegations concerning an engineering report and repair assurances did not establish a basis for MMPA liability.
The ruling resolved the MMPA claim in the contractor’s favor, eliminating any claim for attorney’s fees and statutory damages under the MMPA. The remaining contract and warranty issues were outside the scope of the ruling.
















